A Heartwarming Holiday Experience: A Review of the All Creatures Great and Small Christmas Special on Channel 5
The beleaguered BBC must be regretting its decision to pass on the opportunity to acquire the delightful revival of All Creatures Great and Small on Channel 5. This show, rich in charm and nostalgia, feels like it would fit perfectly into the Sunday evening lineup on BBC One. Imagine a blend of Call the Midwife, but instead of East London nuns, we have Yorkshire veterinarians caring for their adorable animal companions.
Titled "Comfort and Joy," this festive episode truly encapsulated the essence of the holiday season. Right from the modified opening credits, showcasing the Dales covered in a blanket of snow, viewers were immersed in the spirit of Christmas.
Set in December 1945, during the first peacetime Christmas after the war, the storyline cleverly reflects the challenges of that era. With poultry in short supply, housekeeper Mrs. Hall, played by Anna Madeley, sets her sights on winning the darts tournament at the Drovers Arms, with a fresh turkey as the prize. If she fails, they would have to settle for a rather unappealing dish called “murkey,” which is simply a stuffing mixture wrapped in bacon, served alongside roast parsnip legs.
With Helen Herriot, portrayed by Rachel Shenton, feeling under the weather, her husband James—played by Nicholas Ralph—steps up to direct the Darrowby Nativity. However, their mischievous son Jimmy, portrayed by Thomas Riches, keeps introducing himself as the “Angel Gabriel, who has come down from Hebden,” adding chaos to the proceedings.
Meanwhile, the ever-charming Siegfried Farnon, brought to life by Samuel West, finds himself dealing with a troublesome goat that has consumed a potentially hazardous laurel wreath. James is concerned about Tricki Woo’s chances of becoming a father and dreads breaking the news to Mrs. Pumphrey, the doting owner of the pampered Pekingese dog. Tristan, played by Callum Woodhouse, should be celebrating his demobilization, but is clearly haunted by his wartime experiences.
Siegfried's frustration escalates when a kind-hearted lady attempts to play matchmaker for him, saying he’s a misanthropic misfit who should consider a dalliance with a donkey. To his surprise, an old flame, Dorothy (Maimie McCoy), returns from Malta, which stirs up unexpected feelings. Mrs. Hall, ever the romantic, seems to take on the role of Cupid, but can we sense a hint of jealousy?
The chemistry between West and Madeley shines brightly, making them the true stars of this series. Their relationship, filled with longing glances and unspoken affection, rivals any will-they-won’t-they scenarios on television today.
Visually, the rolling landscapes are as stunning as ever, providing a backdrop for heartwarming moments that include gentle humor and tender romance. It's remarkable how quotes from literary figures like Robert Herrick and Aristophanes can coexist on-screen with a comical yet flatulent nanny goat and a rabbit that appears to be shedding tears.
The episode also includes a visit to a Christmas tree farm and an endearing Nativity play that strikes just the right balance without being overly sentimental. Picture shepherds donning tea towels, cardboard-winged angels, a doll with a wobbly head playing baby Jesus, and various dogs in supporting roles.
Despite the festive cheer, the lingering shadow of war adds a layer of poignancy to the celebrations, reminding us of the sacrifices made. When the Christmas lights are finally illuminated after years of darkness, Tristan raises a toast to those lost. As the residents of Skeldale House joyfully exclaim, "Merry bloody Christmas!"
Be sure to catch the All Creatures Great and Small Christmas Special airing at 9 PM on Channel 5 on December 24, and it's available for streaming on their platform.
